01660526

Component

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118777602

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118777602

The capacity of a freeway segment is a critical factor for planning, design, and operational analysis of freeway facilities. This research aimed to perform a comparison among well-known freeway capacity estimation methods in order to investigate their application, as well as their advantages and disadvantages. Single estimate capacity methods such as the Van Aerde method, and breakdown probability methods, such as the product limit method (PLM), the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) method, and the sustainable flow index (SFI) method, were applied at six merge bottleneck locations in the Kansas City area. The results from all methods were compared and the advantages and the disadvantages of each method were discussed. The HCM results showed a significant variability in the estimated breakdown probability function and the resulting capacities. The HCM method was also found to be sensitive to the breakdown probability ratios as a single breakdown observation can significantly shift the fitted distribution and the corresponding capacity estimate. The PLM model provided the highest capacity estimates, followed by the Van Aerde model capacities. The Van Aerde capacities were also found to be closer to the average pre-breakdown flow rates. Finally, the PLM and the SFI method showed consistent performance in comparison to the remaining methods, and flexibility in being applied on different sites with various characteristics.

18-03976

English

pp 75-84

2018

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

Print

Figures (3) ; References (17) ; Tables (4)

Alternatives analysis; Estimating; Freeways; Highway capacity; Methodology

Kansas City (Kansas)

Highways; Planning and Forecasting

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 8 2018 10:59AM

• Assessing Highway Travel Time Reliability using Probe Vehicle Data
• Defining Freeway Design Capacity Based on Stochastic Observations
• Estimating Passenger Car Equivalents on Level Freeway Segments Experiencing High Truck Percentages and Differential Average Speeds
• Evaluation of the Roundabout Capacity Model in HCM6 Edition and HCM 2010 on a Multilane Roundabout
• Impact Assessment of Short-Term Work Zones on Intersection Capacity in New York City
• Investigating Entry Capacity Models of Roundabouts under Heterogeneous Traffic Conditions
• Modeling Free-flow Speeds on Undivided Roads in Mixed Traffic with Weak Lane Discipline
• Modeling the Impacts of Traffic Flow Arrival Profiles on Ramp Metering Queues
• Multimodal Level of Service Methodologies: Evaluation of the Multimodal Performance of Arterial Corridors
• Saturation Flow Model for Signalized Intersection under Mixed Traffic Condition
• Total Capacity of Roundabouts Analyzed by a Conflict Technique
• Traffic Operations on Rural Two-Lane Highways: A Review on Performance Measures and Indicators
• Validation and Calibration of Freeway Reliability Methodology in the Highway Capacity Manual: Method and Case Studies