01594259

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2544-10

Transit smart card data can be analyzed for a number of planning applications, but not all smart card systems produce data of similarly high quality. The primary objective of this research is to evaluate the usefulness and validity of smart card data that are constrained by strong privacy protections and a limited penetration rate. In addition, a method is proposed to mitigate the biases inherent in the data. This analysis, done for the Clipper Card system in the San Francisco Bay Area of California, provides evidence for other agencies seeking to understand the value and limitations of their own data. The evaluation finds that the major limitation of the data is that a combination of the card technology, data coding, and privacy restrictions prevents the transaction location from being identified when the tag-on occurs on a vehicle instead of at a station. Several biases are identified in the users of Clipper Cards in terms of when the data are compared with external data sources, including automated passenger counters and onboard survey data. The onboard survey data are used to estimate a discrete choice model of Clipper Card use. The reciprocal of the modeled probability of using a Clipper Card is proposed as a correction factor. The proposed correction factor is found to mitigate, but not to eliminate fully, the biases in Clipper use. In spite of these limitations, the data are found to be valuable for certain applications, such as identifying transfers. Recommendations are provided for how the data can be improved.

01588888

16-6325

English

0000-0001-8133-3381

pp 81–89

2016

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309441346

Print

Figures (2) ; References (16) ; Tables (3)

Automatic data collection systems; Choice models; Data analysis; Data quality; Privacy; Public transit; Smart cards

Clipper Card

San Francisco Bay Area

Data and Information Technology; Operations and Traffic Management; Public Transportation

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 12 2016 6:48PM

• Analysis of Grid Cell–Based Taxi Ridership with Large-Scale GPS Data
• Bus Network Microsimulation with General Transit Feed Specification and Tap-in-Only Smart Card Data
• BusViz: Big Data for Bus Fleets
• Evaluating Off-Peak Pricing Strategies in Public Transportation with an Activity-Based Approach
• Impact of a Loan-Based Public Transport Fare System on Fare Evasion: Experience of Transantiago, Santiago, Chile
• Inferring Public Transport Access Distance from Smart Card Registration and Transaction Data
• Nonadditive Public Transit Fare Pricing Under Congestion with Policy Lessons from a Case Study in Toronto, Ontario, Canada
• Perspectives on Transit: Potential Benefits of Visualizing Transit Data
• Predicting Express Train Choice of Metro Passengers from Smart Card Data
• Rail Transit Ridership: Station-Area Analysis of Boston’s Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority
• Reducing Subway Crowding: Analysis of an Off-Peak Discount Experiment in Hong Kong
• Social and Distributional Effects of Public Transport Fares and Subsidy Policies: Case of Madrid, Spain
• Toward a Demand Estimation Model Based on Automated Vehicle Location
• Use of Mobile Device Wireless Signals to Determine Transit Route-Level Passenger Origin–Destination Flows: Methodology and Empirical Evaluation
• Use of Mobile Ticketing Data to Estimate an Origin–Destination Matrix for New York City Ferry Service