01475662

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2399-05

http://scholar.google.com...uchi&publication_year=2013

A fuzzy inference approach that ranks proposals for major transit projects is proposed, and its performance is compared with the existing approach used by the FTA New Starts Program. The FTA approach uses a rigid mathematical process in which 24 attributes of a proposal are scored initially and then aggregated multiple times to obtain a single overall rating for the proposal. The proposal’s funding recommendation is based on this rating. In this approach, a small difference in the initial score can make a significant difference in the final score; that is, the final score is not stable with respect to small perturbations in the initial scores of the attributes. In any evaluation, there is always room for subjective judgment and associated uncertainty to enter when the score of an attribute, the break points on the scoring scale, and the value of the weights of the attributes are determined. The proposed fuzzy inference approach incorporates the fuzziness and approximation associated with the evaluation process and preserves them through the calculation process. In this study, data from the 2012 and 2013 reports of the FTA New Starts Program proposal evaluation were used to compare the FTA approach with the proposed approach. The proposed fuzzy inference approach was found to be robust in dealing with evaluator uncertainty in the initial scores. The final score of this method was found to be more stable than that of the FTA method with respect to small changes in initial values, weights, and break points on the performance scale.

01517323

13-3173

English

pp 44–53

2013

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309294843

Print

Figures (9) ; References (17)

Approximation (Mathematics); Evaluation; Fuzzy logic; Programming (Planning); Public transit; Ratings; Uncertainty

New Starts Program; U.S. Federal Transit Administration

Administration and Management; Data and Information Technology; Highways; Planning and Forecasting; I70: Traffic and Transport

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Feb 5 2013 12:38PM

• ASSIST-ME: Postprocessing Tool for Transportation Planning Model Output
• Data Density Requirements as Functions of Design Speed: Controlling Accuracy of Representation of Horizontal and Vertical Curves in Surface Models for Automated Machine Guidance
• Feasibility and Advantages of Estimating Local Road Vehicle Miles Traveled on Basis of Global Positioning System Travel Data
• Large-Scale Agent-Based Transport Simulation in Shanghai, China
• Prediction of Individual Travel Mode with Evidential Neural Network Model
• Spatial Approach for Assessing Energy-Related Impacts on Transportation Systems
• Spatiotemporal Data Warehouse for Vehicle Supervision: Grid Time–Indexed Cube Approach
• Stochastic Network Design Problem with Fuzzy Goals
• Systems Thinking for Knowledge Transfer in Organic and Mechanistic Organizations: State Government Transportation Research Organizations
• Testing and Comparing Neural Network and Statistical Approaches for Predicting Transportation Time Series
• Translating Transportation Data Between Linear Referencing Systems of Dissimilar Resolution