01043487

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2011-10

http://scholar.google.com...rard&publication_year=2007

The analysis of data from state inspection and maintenance (I/M) programs and remote-sensing studies has revealed a number of fundamental insights about vehicle emissions. These include a deterioration effect (emissions increase as vehicles age) and the vintage effect (because of technological improvements, newer model year vehicles are cleaner at any given age than older model year vehicles). As a result, vehicle age and vehicle mileage (from odometer readings) are both important proxies for estimating deterioration and identifying high-emitting vehicles. In this paper, Colorado data are used to demonstrate systematic problems with odometer readings from state I/M data. The paper shows that odometer readings are notoriously poor indicators of actual vehicle miles because of the rollover of five-digit odometers (i.e., from 99,999 to 0) and recording errors. Visual inspection of a distribution of I/M records plotted against odometer readings shows obvious issues with the use of raw odometer readings and implausibly high emissions levels for low-mileage vehicles. A three-part iterative process for identifying and correcting these readings is proposed. After the method is applied, it is found that the rollover problem affects roughly 1 in 20 of the observations in the data set. The problem is particularly acute for older model year vehicles, and negative correlations are observed between miles driven and emissions for certain model years. The results suggest that some results of empirical studies of I/M data need to be reexamined and that emissions improvements resulting from technical change may be overstated.

01083340

English

pp 87-97

2007

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309104371

Print

Figures (10) ; References (11) ; Tables (2)

Errors; Exhaust gases; Inspection; Iterative methods; Odometers; Remote sensing; Vehicle miles of travel

Data correction; Mileage; Model year (Motor vehicles); Systematic errors; Vehicle age

Colorado

Energy; Environment; Highways; Vehicles and Equipment; I15: Environment; I90: Vehicles

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Feb 8 2007 7:35PM

• Commercial Bus Emissions and Fuel Use: Idling Versus Urban Circulator
• Current Department of Transportation Environmental Management System Development Efforts: Examples from Construction, Maintenance, Project Development, and Planning
• Developing the Integrated Transportation and Ecological Enhancements for Montana Process: Applying the "Eco-Logical" Approach
• Development of Silt Fence Tieback Design Methodology for Highway Construction Installations
• Deviation from Standard State Noise Wall Policy
• Diesel Truck Idling Emissions: Measurements at PM2.5 Hot Spot
• Estimation of Impact of Electronic Toll Collection on Air Pollution Levels: Estimation Using Microscopic Simulation Model of Large-Scale Transportation Network
• Evaluating Air Quality Benefits of Freeway High-Occupancy Vehicle Lanes in Southern California
• Global and Country Inventory of Road Passenger and Freight Transportation: Fuel Consumption and Emissions of Air Pollutants in Year 2000
• Impact of Asphalt Rubber Friction Course Overlays on Tire Wear Emissions and Air Quality Models for Phoenix, Arizona, Airshed
• Incorporating Geophysical Remote Sensing into Transportation Archeological Investigations
• Integrating Vehicle Emission Modeling with Activity-Based Travel Demand Modeling: Case Study of the Greater Toronto, Canada, Area
• Interactive Forecasting Tool for Impact of New Engine Technologies on Fuel Consumption and Emissions
• Mix Design and Benefit Evaluation of High Solar Reflectance Concrete for Pavements
• Modeling On-Road Particle Number Emissions from a Hybrid Diesel–Electric Bus: Exploratory Econometric Analysis
• Potential for Local "Bring-Sites" to Reduce Householder Recycling Mileage
• Recycling Construction and Demolition Waste for Construction in Kansas City Metropolitan Area, Kansas and Missouri
• Stochastic Model for Estimating Impact of Highway Incidents on Air Pollution and Traffic Delay
• Supplemental Metrics to Communicate Aircraft Noise Effects
• Urban Transport Scenarios in South Asia: Energy and Environmental Impact of Enhanced Public Transport Systems
• Use of Highway Underpasses by Large Mammals and Other Wildlife in Virginia: Factors Influencing Their Effectiveness