00936060

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/1811-03

http://scholar.google.com...ulos&publication_year=2002

Recent public opposition threatened to eliminate ramp control as a traffic management option in the Twin Cities of Minneapolis and St. Paul, which have one of the most extensive ramp control systems in the nation. In response to this, the Minnesota Department of Transportation had to produce tangible independent evidence that ramp metering is effective, to avoid turning off the meters. Simulation is the most widely accepted technique for achieving the stated objectives without turning the metering system off, and therefore it was used in this study. Two freeway sections were selected for detailed testing, and the results along with the methodology are presented here. The results confirm that ramp metering is effective on the ramp and freeway system (not just the freeway), but they also revealed excessive delays on certain ramps that appear to support the concerns raised by the users. Real-life issues related to the simulation implementation process (data collection and filtering, calibration, and interpreting and summarizing results) are also presented. Through the course of this work, simulation reliability was established by defining a successful calibration and validation methodology and by identifying, in the process, certain operational problems related to the deployed surveillance and control system that had been unknown. Finally, a general methodology was developed for evaluation that can easily be adapted to any user-specified control strategy or used to improve an already existing one without field disruptions.

This paper appears in Transportation Research Record No. 1811, Advanced Traffic Management Systems for Freeways and Traffic Signal Systems 2002.

English

p. 21-29

2002

Transportation Research Record

0309077370

Figures (1) ; References (11) ; Tables (4)

Calibration; Data collection; Freeways; Problem identification; Ramp metering; Simulation; Test sections; Traffic delays; Traffic signal control systems; Traffic surveillance; Validation

Data filtering

Twin Cities Metropolitan Area (Minnesota)

Highways; Operations and Traffic Management; I73: Traffic Control

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 7 2003 12:00AM

• ADAPTIVE SIGNAL CONTROL SYSTEM WITH ONLINE PERFORMANCE MEASURE FOR A SINGLE INTERSECTION
• AUTOMATIC REAL-TIME DETECTION AND CORRECTION OF ERRONEOUS DETECTOR DATA WITH FOURIER TRANSFORMS FOR ONLINE TRAFFIC CONTROL ARCHITECTURES
• BUS PRIORITY WITH HIGHLY INTERRUPTIBLE TRAFFIC SIGNAL CONTROL: SIMULATION OF SAN JUAN'S AVENIDA PONCE DE LEON
• DYNAMIC SIGNAL COORDINATION FOR NETWORKS WITH OVERSATURATED INTERSECTIONS
• EVALUATION OF TRAFFIC FLOW ANALYSIS TOOLS APPLIED TO WORK ZONES BASED ON FLOW DATA COLLECTED IN THE FIELD
• FIELD OPERATIONAL TEST OF INTEGRATED FREEWAY RAMP METERING/ARTERIAL ADAPTIVE SIGNAL CONTROL: LESSONS LEARNED IN IRVINE, CALIFORNIA
• FREEWAY PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT SYSTEM: OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS TOOL
• FREEWAY TRAVEL TIME PREDICTION WITH STATE-SPACE NEURAL NETWORKS: MODELING STATE-SPACE DYNAMICS WITH RECURRENT NEURAL NETWORKS
• INTEGRATED CONTROL STRATEGIES FOR SURFACE STREET AND FREEWAY SYSTEMS
• MOBILE SENSOR AND SAMPLE-BASED ALGORITHM FOR FREEWAY INCIDENT DETECTION
• MONITORING COMMUTER CONGESTION ON SURFACE STREETS IN REAL TIME
• OPTIMIZED POLICIES FOR ADAPTIVE CONTROL STRATEGY IN REAL-TIME TRAFFIC ADAPTIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS: IMPLEMENTATION AND FIELD TESTING
• OPTIMIZING TRAFFIC NETWORK SIGNALS AROUND RAILROAD CROSSINGS: MODEL VALIDATIONS
• PREDICTION OF TRAFFIC-ACTUATED PHASE TIMES ON ARTERIAL STREETS
• PROGRAM FOR OPTIMIZING DIAMOND INTERCHANGES IN OVERSATURATED CONDITIONS
• QUANTIFYING DELAY REDUCTION TO BUSES WITH SIGNAL PRIORITY TREATMENT IN MIXED-MODE OPERATION
• REALIZING BENEFITS OF ADAPTIVE SIGNAL CONTROL AT AN ISOLATED INTERSECTION
• TRANSFERABILITY OF A STOCHASTIC TOLL PLAZA COMPUTER MODEL
• USE OF LOCAL LANE DISTRIBUTION PATTERNS TO ESTIMATE MISSING DATA VALUES FROM TRAFFIC MONITORING SYSTEMS