01626023

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2605-09

Through direct democracy, the voting public can engage in ballot box planning, by which voters themselves, rather than decision makers, set policy and make project decisions. Previous studies found that ballot box planning has a growing influence on land use policy as well as transportation and land use finance. However, the impact of ballot box planning on transportation policy is relatively unexplored. This paper examines 148 local transportation policy–related ballot measures in California from 1995 to 2015. Most transportation policy measures passed, but measures that could be classified as proalternative or anticar passed at a slightly higher rate than did procar or antialternative measures and showed some agreement between voters and transportation professionals toward multimodalism. Nonetheless, there are numerous examples of voters constraining the options of transportation planners by restricting or even prohibiting contemporary planning strategies. For example, several successful ballot measures took aim at priced parking, red light cameras, and roundabouts. Ballot measures also can create uncertainty through a ballot box volleyball effect, by which policies and project decisions vacillate between two extremes depending on the results of several ballot measures on the same topic. For such reasons, it has been argued that ballot box planning is a deliberative failure in planning and counteracts the best-laid plans of elected officials and planning practitioners.

01629557

17-05573

English

0000-0003-4284-2882

pp 92–98

2017

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309441865

Digital/other

References (20) ; Tables (9)

Land use planning; Local government; Political factors; Transportation policy

Democracy

California

Economics; Policy; Society; Transportation (General)

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Dec 8 2016 12:13PM

• Assessing Nighttime Deliveries in Stockholm, Sweden
• Assessing the State of Practice of the Role and Siting Issues Related to Curbless Streets in an Urban Context
• Assessment of Three Affiliated Tribes Primary Seat Belt Intervention
• Ballpark Method for Estimating Pedestrian and Bicyclist Exposure in Seattle, Washington: Potential Option for Resource-Constrained Cities in an Age of Big Data
• Data-Driven Urban Performance Measures: Case Study Application in the District of Columbia
• Equity of Bikeway Distribution in Minneapolis, Minnesota
• Improving Travel Quality of Low-Income Commuters in China: Demand-Side Perspective
• Measuring the Impact of the Trans-European Road Transport Network on the Accessibility of European Urban Agglomerations
• Performance-Based Methodology for Evaluating Equity for Transportation System Users
• Revamping Tribal Road Networks from Various Sources and Improving Quality
• To Share or Not To Share: Investigating the Social Aspects of Dynamic Ridesharing
• Understanding Livable Streets in the Context of the Arterials That Surround Them