01590118

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2568-10

Governments face critical decisions on how to spend taxpayers’ money and must weigh priorities and come to these decisions in a transparent and defensible way. A prioritization tool can play a critical role in informing spending decisions, ensuring that decisions are made in the interest of the public good, and bolstering public confidence in elected officials and the democratic process. Ideally, a prioritization tool not only evaluates potential projects against a desired set of policy objectives but also prioritizes potential projects into an implementation plan through the integration of pragmatic considerations. Metrolinx, an Ontario, Canada, provincial agency tasked with transportation planning for the greater Toronto and Hamilton area, developed a prioritization framework to make recommendations on capital investment in sustainable transportation. This paper summarizes the current prioritization framework, outlines its limitations, and goes on to explore potential remedies to those limitations as well as inherent challenges. Specifically, the paper discusses incorporating broader considerations, including multimodal integration and active transportation, congestion, network effects, and project interdependencies, and bridging the gap between project evaluation and real-world prioritization. The paper presents best-practice research for each broader consideration and posits that these broader considerations can be used to transform evaluation outputs into prioritized implementation plans.

01593395

16-0472

English

pp 64–71

2016

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309441254

Print

Figures (1) ; References (13) ; Tables (1)

Best practices; Decision support systems; Multimodal transportation; Public transit; Strategic planning; Sustainable transportation; Traffic congestion; Transportation planning

Toronto (Canada)

Administration and Management; Planning and Forecasting; Public Transportation

PRP, TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 12 2016 4:22PM

• Development of Improved Trip Attraction Rates for Small and Medium-Sized Travel Demand Models
• Estimating Parking Utilization in Multifamily Residential Buildings in Washington, D.C.
• Evaluating Sustainability Planning Under California’s Senate Bill 375
• How the Poor Commute in Bangkok, Thailand
• Impacts of Property Accessibility and Neighborhood Built Environment on Single-Unit and Multiunit Residential Property Values
• Improving Decision Making for Transportation Capacity Expansion: Qualitative Analysis of Best Practices for Regional Transportation Plans
• Maximizing Statewide Multimodal Transportation Systems: Looking to Transportation Option Solutions in Oregon
• New Horizontal Equity Measure for Ramp Meters
• Signals from the Crowd: Strategic Management and Learning Through Crowdsourcing
• Traffic Safety Along Tourist Routes in Rural Areas
• Transportation System Health: Meeting Deficiency Needs and Growth Aspirations Systemically
• Travel Model Blind Spots: Importance of Understanding Special Markets Related to Visitors