01128812

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2132-09

http://scholar.google.com...olak&publication_year=2009

The ultimate objective of most practical transport modeling is the evaluation of the economic impacts of alternative policy measures. During the past decade, significant advances have been made in the ability of operational models to accommodate flexible patterns of taste heterogeneity. The majority of applications use parametric distributions in which the parameters of the distribution are specified a priori. However, in reality individual tastes rarely follow a standard distribution, especially in the extremes of the distribution in which behavior is likely to differ substantially from that of the rest of the population. The major problem in these cases is the suitability of estimated models for determining economic welfare because they may yield erroneous or counterintuitive results. Recent research proposes using nonparametric models to capture randomness in individuals’ tastes, in which the shape of the unknown distribution is defined as part of the estimation process. But there is still no evidence regarding the implication of using these more advanced model structures for determining economic welfare. The aim of this paper is to investigate to what extent imposing a well-shaped distribution of individual tastes affects the appraisal of transport policy measures. In particular the focus is on random taste heterogeneity. With the use of simulated data, an investigation is done on how parametric and nonparametric models perform under different assumptions for true taste distributions. Finally, implications of the accuracy of alternative methods of computing benefit measures are critically analyzed.

01147879

09-2505

English

pp 78-86

2009

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309142632

Print

Figures (1) ; References (25) ; Tables (5)

Economic impacts; Nonparametric analysis; Parametric analysis; Randomization; Simulation; Transportation policy; User benefits; Welfare economics

Heterogeneity (Choices)

Highways; Planning and Forecasting; Public Transportation; I72: Traffic and Transport Planning

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 30 2009 6:52PM

• Adding Mode Choice to Multiagent Transport Simulation
• Artificial Neural Network Delay Model for Traffic Assignment Incorporating Intersection Delay Costs
• Continuous Departure Time Models: A Bayesian Approach
• Enhanced Destination Choice Models Incorporating Agglomeration Related to Trip Chaining While Controlling for Spatial Competition
• Estimating Random Coefficient Logit Models with Full Covariance Matrix: Comparing Performance of Mixed Logit and Laplace Approximation Methods
• Evacuation Planning Using the Integrated System of Activity-Based Modeling and Dynamic Traffic Assignment
• Heterogeneous Decision Rule Model of Mode Choice Incorporating Utility Maximization and Disutility Minimization
• How Travel Attributes Affect Planning Time Horizon of Activities
• Large Problems of Dynamic Network Assignment and Traffic Equilibrium: Computational Principles and Application to Paris Road Network
• Methods for Generating Connectors in Transport Planning Models
• Model for Person and Household Mobility Attributes
• Review of International Modeling Literature: Transit, Land Use, and Automobile Pricing Strategies to Reduce Vehicle Miles Traveled and Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• TRANSIMS Implementation in Chittenden County, Vermont: Development, Calibration, and Preliminary Sensitivity Analysis
• Understanding and Accommodating Risk and Uncertainty in Toll Road Projects: A Review of the Literature
• Work Departure Time Analysis Using Dogit Ordered Generalized Extreme Value Model