01128639

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2132-12

http://scholar.google.com...lman&publication_year=2009

Forecasting traffic and toll revenues for new highway projects involves great uncertainty because of the inherent uncertainty in the models used to make forecasts. As private investment becomes more common in project financing, quantifying the levels of risk and uncertainty associated with such projects becomes critical. This paper represents a review of many key studies and reports dealing with uncertainty in traffic and revenue forecasts for highway projects. These studies found that tolled projects tend to suffer from substantial optimism bias in forecasts, with predicted traffic volumes exceeding actual volumes by 30% or more about half the time. Moreover, projects with greater uncertainty tend to overestimate Year 1 traffic volumes more and stabilize at lower final traffic volumes. But after one controls for added optimism bias in traffic forecasts (compared with nontolled projects), there is little difference in uncertainty levels between tolled and nontolled forecasts. A typical way to address uncertainty in traffic forecasts is through sensitivity testing via variations in key inputs and parameters. A more extensive and less arbitrary version of this, Monte Carlo simulation, can provide probability distributions of future traffic and revenue, although it tends to require many simulations, demanding greater computational effort and time, unless networks are streamlined. Nonetheless, if reasonable assumptions for model input and parameter distributions can be made, Monte Carlo simulation generates a variety of useful information and establishes the actual likelihood of loss (rather than more basic win–lose indicators from a limited set of stress tests).

01147879

09-2027

English

pp 106-112

2009

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309142632

Print

Figures (2) ; References (35)

Forecasting; Literature reviews; Monte Carlo method; Private enterprise; Revenues; Risk analysis; Toll roads; Traffic forecasting; Traffic simulation; Uncertainty

Highway projects; Private investment

Finance; Highways; Planning and Forecasting; I72: Traffic and Transport Planning

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 30 2009 6:20PM

• Adding Mode Choice to Multiagent Transport Simulation
• Artificial Neural Network Delay Model for Traffic Assignment Incorporating Intersection Delay Costs
• Assessment of User Benefits in Presence of Random Taste Heterogeneity: Comparison of Parametric and Nonparametric Models
• Continuous Departure Time Models: A Bayesian Approach
• Enhanced Destination Choice Models Incorporating Agglomeration Related to Trip Chaining While Controlling for Spatial Competition
• Estimating Random Coefficient Logit Models with Full Covariance Matrix: Comparing Performance of Mixed Logit and Laplace Approximation Methods
• Evacuation Planning Using the Integrated System of Activity-Based Modeling and Dynamic Traffic Assignment
• Heterogeneous Decision Rule Model of Mode Choice Incorporating Utility Maximization and Disutility Minimization
• How Travel Attributes Affect Planning Time Horizon of Activities
• Large Problems of Dynamic Network Assignment and Traffic Equilibrium: Computational Principles and Application to Paris Road Network
• Methods for Generating Connectors in Transport Planning Models
• Model for Person and Household Mobility Attributes
• Review of International Modeling Literature: Transit, Land Use, and Automobile Pricing Strategies to Reduce Vehicle Miles Traveled and Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• TRANSIMS Implementation in Chittenden County, Vermont: Development, Calibration, and Preliminary Sensitivity Analysis
• Work Departure Time Analysis Using Dogit Ordered Generalized Extreme Value Model