01658526

Component

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118786473

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118786473

The 1974 paper by Treiterer and Myers is a seminal work in traffic flow theory. This longevity is in part because of the impressive collection of manually extracted vehicle trajectories. To date, only a few studies have rivaled the scale of the empirical vehicle trajectory data used in Treiterer and Myers. Their data collection used high-speed aerial photography and manual data reduction to follow hundreds of vehicles. In spite of the Herculean collection effort, the trajectory data set was never released and has since been lost. Fortunately, the plots survive and the present work re-extracts the vehicle trajectory data from the time–space diagrams. The discussion places the value of the data in context and then uses the data to put an end to decades of misinterpretation that started with Treiterer himself. The central thesis of Treiterer and Myers generated considerable interest: a hysteresis whereby drivers exhibit different fundamental behavior depending on whether they are entering or exiting a disturbance. There has been extensive debate about the authors’ findings in the literature, but without the original data set any interpretation has required considerable speculation. With the resurrected trajectories, this work reexamines the vehicles underlying the hysteresis and finally quells the speculation. Rather than arising from car following behavior, it turns out that the enigmatic progression arose from a combination of lane change maneuvers and unremarkable transitions into or out of the congested regime. On publication, the re-extracted data from this paper will be released to the research community.

18-00020

English

pp 25-38

2018

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

Print

Figures (8) ; References (28) ; Tables (1)

Aerial photography; Data collection; Hysteresis; Traffic flow theory; Trajectory

Treiterer, Joseph

Highways; Operations and Traffic Management; Vehicles and Equipment

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Jan 8 2018 10:02AM

• A Macroscopic Multi-Lane Traffic Flow Model for ACC/CACC Traffic Dynamics
• A New Control Strategy Integrated into the Desired Safety Margin Car-Following Model Considering the Disturbance Level
• A Platooning Strategy for Automated Vehicles in the Presence of Speed Limit Fluctuations
• A Simple Example of a Two-Dimensional Model for Traffic: Discussion about Assumptions and Numerical Methods
• Application of a Discontinuous Form of Macroscopic Gazis–Herman–Rothery Model to Steady-State Freeway Traffic Stream Observations
• Control of Connected and Autonomous Vehicles with Cut-in Movement using Spring Mass Damper System
• Evaluating Recurring Traffic Congestion using Change Point Regression and Random Variation Markov Structured Model
• Extended Desired Safety Margin Car-Following Model That Considers Variation of Historical Perceived Risk and Acceptable Risk
• Improved Numerical Method for Aw-Rascle Type Continuum Traffic Flow Models
• Introducing a Re-Sampling Methodology for the Estimation of Empirical Macroscopic Fundamental Diagrams
• Investigating Transfer Flow between Urban Networks Based on a Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram
• Model for Planning and Sizing Curbside Parking Lanes in Urban Networks
• Modeling and Evaluating Traffic Flow at Sag Curves When Imposing Variable Speed Limits on Connected Vehicles
• Modeling Driver Merging Behavior: A Repeated Game Theoretical Approach
• Multi-Thread Optimization for the Calibration of Microscopic Traffic Simulation Model
• Off-Ramp Coupling Conditions Devoid of Spurious Blocking and Re-Routing
• Optimizing Transit Signal Priority Implementation along an Arterial
• Perimeter Control as an Alternative to Dedicated Bus Lanes: A Case Study
• Real-Time Estimation of Lane Change Risks Based on the Analysis of Individual Vehicle Interactions
• Some Indications on How to Calibrate the Social Force Model of Pedestrian Dynamics
• Traffic Flow of Merging Pedestrian Crowds: How Architectural Design Affects Collective Movement Efficiency
• Traffic Shockwave Detection in a Connected Environment using the Speed Distribution of Individual Vehicles