01666280

Component

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118758286

https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118758286

Legalization is often a policy solution to perceived problems of inefficient and unsafe operation of informal buses in developing countries. Facing the world’s second worst road safety record, the Thai government is set to ban the use of vans for intercity bus services and is considering banning individual operators and requiring them to form a legal entity. A question thus arises whether an operator’s legal status significantly affects bus safety. This paper aims to answer that question by analyzing route-level data on accidents and legal status of intercity bus operators. The results of Poisson and negative binomial regression analyses confirm that the use of vans increases accident and fatality risks of intercity bus services. But the evidence does not support the government’s claim that requiring operators to register as legal entities would make intercity services safer. For long-distance routes, more bus companies mean greater accident risks. The only situation where more individual operators mean higher safety risks is with fatality rates on long-distance routes. However, fatality rates are actually lower with more individual operators on short-distance routes. This is likely because most individual operators on short-distance routes belong to informal operator groups that adopt internal rules and procedures to govern members’ behaviors. The key policy implications are that mandatory legal registration of operators does not automatically enhance bus safety, and that safety measures should focus on operational characteristics and actual practice.

18-01733

English

pp 99-109

2018

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

Print

Figures (1) ; References (19) ; Tables (3)

Bus routes; Bus transportation; Crash rates; Crash risk forecasting; Fatalities; Legal factors; Registration; Regression analysis; Traffic safety; Transit operators; Vans

Thailand

Law; Public Transportation; Safety and Human Factors; Vehicles and Equipment

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Dec 22 2017 10:35AM

• Cyclist Satisfaction Evaluation Model for Free-Floating Bike-Sharing System: A Case Study of Shanghai
• Impact of Curbside Parking on Bicycle Lane Capacity in Nanjing, China
• Influence of Socioeconomic Conditions on Crash Injury Severity for an Urban Area in a Developing Country
• Interactions between Driving Skills on Aggressive Driving: Study among Chinese Drivers
• Macroscopic Spatial Analysis of Pedestrian Crashes in Medellin, Colombia
• Measuring the Passenger Car Equivalent of Small Cars and SUVs on Rainy and Sunny Days
• Modeling Pedestrian Crossing Behavior and Safety at Signalized Intersections
• Modeling the Gender Effects of Pedestrians and Calibration of the Modified Social Force Model
• Performance Comparison of Bus Travel Time Prediction Models across Indian Cities
• Study on the Invasion Behavior of E-Bikes with Motor Vehicle Traffic at a Signalized Intersection
• Using Open Source Data to Measure Street Walkability and Bikeability in China: A Case of Four Cities