01631531

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2608-09

The economic assessment of transportation projects is evolving from a reliance on user benefits (travel time, cost, or safety) to encompass a wider spectrum of potential benefits, fostered by advances in economics and recognition that different project modes deliver different portfolios of benefits. Sponsors develop projects to address specific problems in their communities. This progression in how investments are evaluated opens the door for projects whose outcomes span a variety of benefit categories rather than concentrating on traditional user benefits and permits an improved intermodal comparison of candidate investments. Transit and intercity rail projects are particular beneficiaries of the broader project assessment approach. This paper presents a case study of how a comprehensive approach to project assessment was applied to the Northern Lights Express project that would reintroduce passenger rail service between the cities of Minneapolis and Duluth, Minnesota, the state’s largest economies. Owned and operated by BNSF Railway, Amtrak’s service in the corridor ended in 1985. Six stations are planned: Target Field in Minneapolis; stations in Coon Rapids, Cambridge, and Hinckley, Minnesota; a station in Superior, Wisconsin; and Union Depot in Duluth. The goal for the analysis was threefold: (a) to confirm that the investment would yield a positive return; (b) to communicate with partners, stakeholders, and the public about the project’s expected outcomes; and (c) to contribute to the selection of an alternative. The benefit–cost ratio was estimated for eight alternatives that varied by physical alignment and service plan.

01628040

17-05817

English

pp 78–85

2017

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309442084

Digital/other

References (29) ; Tables (2)

Benefit cost analysis; Case studies; Intercity transportation; Passenger trains; Passenger transportation; Railroad transportation

Northern Lights Express

Duluth (Minnesota); Minneapolis (Minnesota)

Economics; Passenger Transportation; Planning and Forecasting; Railroads

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Dec 8 2016 12:20PM

• Bayesian Spatial Models of Crash Frequency at Highway–Railway Crossings
• Cluster-Based Approach to Analyzing Crash Injury Severity at Highway–Rail Grade Crossings
• Comprehensive Approach to Allocate Reliability and Cost in Passenger Rail System Design
• Current Issues in Highway–Rail Grade Crossing Hazard-Ranking and Project Development
• Economics and Planning of Short-Haul and Short-Line Railway Intermodal Service: Lessons from Previous and Current Operations
• Macrolevel Classification Yard Capacity Modeling
• Nested Sorting and Clustering for Visualization of Accidents in Highway–Rail Grade Crossings
• Railway Capacity Allocation Modeling Using a Genetic Algorithm
• Railway Engineering Education Symposium: Evolving to Rebuild a Growing Rail Academic Community
• Railway Human Factors and Operational Issues: What Can We Learn from Locomotive Voice and Video Recorders?
• Risk Comparison of Transporting Hazardous Materials in Unit Trains Versus Mixed Trains
• Survey of Future Railroad Operations and the Role of Automation
• Synthesis of North American High-Speed Passenger Rail Ridership Forecasting
• Train Data Collection and Arrival Time Prediction System for Highway–Rail Grade Crossings