01340340

Component

https://doi.org/10.3141/2221-03

http://scholar.google.com...ford&publication_year=2011

Policy makers have begun to consider replacing state and federal fuel taxes with per mile user charges that would be more financially sustainable. The distributional implications of this change in tax policy are uncertain and raise equity concerns. This study uses data from the 2001 National Household Travel Survey to evaluate the distributional implications of replacing the per-gallon federal fuel tax with an equivalent flat-rate vehicle miles traveled (VMT) fee of 0.98 cent per mile. The analysis indicates that VMT fees will be less regressive than fuel taxes by shifting the burden of taxation from low-income households to high-income households. The results provide new insight on the transportation tax burdens of households at different stages of life and suggest that a VMT fee would shift the tax burden from retired households to younger households with children. Consistent with previous research, VMT fees are shown to shift the tax burden from rural households to urban households. These findings challenge conventional wisdom that VMT fees would be inequitable for low-income and rural households. Overall, a revenue-neutral VMT fee would change the annual tax burden of 98% of the population by less than $20. The small magnitude of these distributional implications suggest that addressing concerns about the equity of VMT fees should, perhaps, take a lower priority relative to other concerns, such as administration costs, evasion, and privacy.

01352851

11-3389

English

pp 19-26

2011

Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board

9780309167321

Print

References (26) ; Tables (4)

Demographics; Equity; Financing; Fuel taxes; Highways; Low income groups; Mileage-based user fees; Socioeconomic factors; Transportation policy; User charges; Vehicle miles of travel

2001 National Household Travel Survey

Finance; Highways; Policy; I10: Economics and Administration

TRIS, TRB, ATRI

Feb 17 2011 6:30PM

• Agglomeration Benefits and Transportation Projects: Review of Theory, Measurement, and Application
• Congestion Pricing Study of San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge in California
• Cost Estimates for Collecting Fees for Vehicle Miles Traveled
• Effectiveness and Equity of Vehicle Mileage Fee at Federal and State Levels
• End of the Highway Trust Fund? Long-Term Options for Funding Federal Surface Transportation
• Measuring Toll Burdens: Applying Lorenz Curves to a Detailed Data Set of Users of Metropolitan Transportation Administration Bridges in New York City
• National Evaluation of Mileage-Based Charges for Drivers: Initial Results
• Peak Period Use of I-15 Corridor in San Diego, California: Long-Term Impact of FasTrak Program
• Reaction to Value Pricing by Different Suburban Populations
• Rethinking the Politics of Freeway Congestion Pricing
• Urban Network Privatization: Example of a Small Network